Economic Recovery Falls to Thrifty Consumers

Inquiring minds are reading the AP story showing that the recovery is coming down to a Catch-22 scenario between employment and spending:

American shoppers are being careful about how much they
spend, and that’s making businesses cautious about hiring.

For the economic recovery to gain strength – and the unemployment rate to come
down in any meaningful way – consumers will need to become less frugal. But a
flurry of data released Tuesday suggests families are reluctant to increase
their spending, even as they buy more stuff, including cars and consumer
staples like razors and shampoo.

“Once the unemployment rate starts coming down in a significant way, consumers
will feel more confident and start spending. But businesses are reluctant to
step up hiring until they see stronger demand,” said Chris G. Christopher,
senior economist at IHS Global Insight. “It’s a Catch-22 situation.”

Unemployment stands at 9.5 percent. The government’s next jobs report comes out

Here is the rest of the article:

Economic Recovery Falls to Thrifty Consumers

By Martin Crutsinger

…General Motors and Chrysler on Tuesday posted higher U.S. sales for July, a
sign that Americans are still willing to buy big-ticket items. And Procter &
Gamble, maker of Tide laundry soap and Pampers diapers, said its revenue grew 5
percent in the latest quarter.

But other industry and government data were more downbeat.

Factory orders dropped in June for the second consecutive month after nine
straight months of gains, the Commerce Department said. And the number of
buyers who signed contracts to purchase homes fell in June to the lowest level
on records dating back to 2001, according to the National Association of

One telling detail about consumers’ habits these days came from the Commerce
Dept.’s personal income and spending report for June: the annualized savings
rate stood at 6.4 percent, the highest level in nearly a year – and triple the
rate in 2007, before the recession.

The savings rate hasn’t dipped below 5 percent since October 2008.

Even the way people are paying for things shows a change in attitude about
money. Consumers shied away from accumulating new debt during the second
quarter, according to the latest reports from MasterCard Inc., and Visa Inc.

Overall card use rose 14 percent. But the growth came almost entirely from
debit cards, which rose to $465 billion, from $408 billion a year ago. Credit
card use edged up less than a percent to $345 billion from $342 billion last

Analysts believe consumers have now rebuilt savings and will be open to
spending more in the coming months.

“We think most of the required increases in savings have already happened and
that further increases in incomes will translate into consumer spending,” said
Peter Newland, an economist at Barclays Capital.

Consumer spending is important because it accounts for 70 percent of total
economic activity.

Last week, the government said economic growth for the second quarter slowed to
2.4 percent. Many analysts believe it will dip further in the second half of
the year because of high unemployment, shaky consumer confidence and weakness
in home prices in many major metropolitan areas.

While personal income growth was flat in June, it rose in April and May. But
households chose to save the extra money rather than spend it.

Longer term, that may not be such a bad thing, economists said, because the
savings help households get control of their bills and make purchases they can

“It is of some comfort that households now appear to have something of a
cushion that can be used to pay down debt or support spending,” said Paul
Dales, U.S. economist at Capital Economics.

Make no mistake, Americans are spending money. But they want value for their
purchases or a good deal. If they don’t get either, many are passing on name
brands and living with generic goods.

The automakers that posted higher U.S. sales in July did so through summer
promotions and easier credit plans.

P&G executives said they’ve noticed shoppers shift to cheaper brands. In
response, the company has cut its prices, offered discounts and created lower-
priced versions of some brands to hold onto customers. This explains why net
income for the quarter was down to $2.2 billion from nearly $2.5 billion a year

“The economic recovery in the United States will be uneven,” Bob McDonald,
president, CEO and chairman, told investors. “I think we are seeing that
already. We don’t expect a double-dip recession … but we have got to keep
innovating and keep growing.”

Saving more and budgeting for purchases may be good for families. But it
worries retailers, who employs 14.4 million Americans, or about 11 percent of
total employment.

Retailers stepped up hiring earlier this year after a solid winter holiday
shopping season, then cut jobs in May and June as consumer spending slowed.

Craig Johnson, president of retail consulting firm Customer Growth Partners,
says stores would prefer Americans saved in the 3 to 4 percent range. But he
expects shoppers to keep squirreling money away at the higher rate even through
the Christmas holiday season.

“This is a real sign that people are very cautious about spending,” he said.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: